WEBVTT

1
00:00:06.871 --> 00:00:10.951
<v Maya>This is CivicFM, with the week at Oakland City Hall.

2
00:00:11.551 --> 00:00:25.231
<v Maya>Oakland's pause on data centers gets about ten and a half more months. A split council vote adds money for executive searches. And a divestment proposal heads to the finance committee, with no date set.

3
00:00:25.231 --> 00:00:32.351
<v Maya>This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

4
00:00:37.573 --> 00:01:00.693
<v Maya>Our top story this week: on Tuesday the City Council voted eight to nothing to extend its emergency moratorium on approving data centers in Oakland by ten months and fifteen days. Three weeks ago we told you the Rules Committee had put this extension on the calendar. The original forty-five-day pause was adopted October sixth and would have expired November twentieth.

5
00:01:00.693 --> 00:01:19.813
<v Theo>City staff said the extension carries their work through October fifth of next year. They're drafting zoning rules on where data centers could go, with limits on power, water and air quality. Staff said they're consulting utilities and regulators, with particular concern about backup generators, and plan to hire outside consultants.

6
00:01:19.813 --> 00:01:41.053
<v Maya>About thirty-four people spoke in public comment. Roughly thirty urged the extension, and about ten said the city should eventually ban data centers for good. They cited West Oakland's pollution and health disparities, higher utility bills, and diesel generators. About four speakers favored allowing data centers, citing jobs and growth.

7
00:01:41.053 --> 00:02:03.573
<v Theo>On the dais, one councilmember said the moratorium isn't a rejection of technology, but guardrails on the industry. Another urged that the definition of a data center not end up restricting light manufacturing, while saying massive GPU farms have no place in Oakland. Staff said they're also weighing a place-based approach, allowing some facilities in some areas but not others.

8
00:02:03.573 --> 00:02:19.093
<v Maya>At-large Councilmember Rowena Brown asked staff for an implementation timeline and a report back within thirty days on outreach, research and hiring consultants. Any new rules go to the Planning Commission and a council committee before they come back to the council.

9
00:02:21.529 --> 00:02:54.969
<v Theo>Now to a split vote on the firms Oakland pays to recruit its top managers. Two weeks ago we told you the Finance and Management Committee cut a request for three hundred thousand dollars more, for two of the city's three search firms, down to seventy-five thousand, for one. On Tuesday the council approved that version, five to two with one abstention. It extends all three contracts and adds the seventy-five thousand to one firm, Ralph Andersen and Associates. Councilmembers Noel Gallo and Janani Ramachandran voted no, and Councilmember Carroll Fife abstained.

10
00:02:54.969 --> 00:03:10.809
<v Maya>Ramachandran chairs the finance committee and opposes any increase. She argued the city spends too much on headhunting firms and often gets poor results, that its own HR staff can recruit, and that these firms aren't local small businesses.

11
00:03:10.809 --> 00:03:40.729
<v Theo>District Seven Councilmember Ken Houston said at first he'd vote no too, citing the waiver of competitive bidding and the firms not being local. Staff said the money would finish searches already under way, including for a constitutional policing administrator. Then the assistant city administrator who oversees human resources apologized for not bringing the request in a timely and transparent way, and said the Mayor wants a professional firm to recruit the city administrator. Here's Councilmember Houston, responding.

12
00:03:41.129 --> 00:03:58.289
<v Ken Houston (Councilmember, District 7) (from the meeting)>I appreciate it, Ms. Phillips, but that's not your fault. I mean, I appreciate you taking that hit. And it's not too many people that can make me change my vote, but I respect you to a whole another level. So I'm going change my vote to yes.

13
00:03:59.194 --> 00:04:11.434
<v Maya>Human resources said it will start a new request for proposals for search firms. Staff also said they'll come back to shift some of another firm's contract authority to Ralph Andersen, at no added cost.

14
00:04:13.940 --> 00:04:36.980
<v Maya>Our third story comes from Thursday's Rules and Legislation Committee, which sets the council's agendas. It voted three to nothing, with Councilmember Ramachandran excused, to put a public proposal for an ethical investment policy on the Finance and Management Committee's pending list, with no date set. The committee decided only where to schedule it, not whether to adopt it.

15
00:04:36.980 --> 00:05:04.900
<v Theo>Members of the public with the Oakland Divest Committee brought it under a council rule that lets members of the public ask for an item to be scheduled. It would bar city investments in companies that facilitate state violence, war and occupation, or severe human rights violations. The agenda lists detention and prison labor industries, defense and military industries, and companies it says facilitate rights violations in Israel's occupation of Palestinian and Syrian lands.

16
00:05:04.900 --> 00:05:38.100
<v Maya>Thirteen people spoke. Seven backed moving it forward, among them speakers for CAIR San Francisco Bay Area and UAW Region Six. Five opposed it, including speakers from the Oakland Jewish Alliance and JCRC Bay Area. They argued it singles out Israel and that the council should focus on local problems. One warned it could hurt the city's credit rating and invite lawsuits, and another that it would force the sale of the city's corporate bonds. One more speaker took neither side.

17
00:05:38.100 --> 00:06:04.420
<v Theo>Council President Kevin Jenkins, who chairs the committee, said this would be the last item scheduled under that part of the rules, and that the rules would be changed. One councilmember said she'd rather look broadly at investments that run counter to the city's values than single out one country, and that she wants to hear from opposing groups too. The finance chair, Ramachandran, was out ill, and the councilmember who seconded the motion said they should connect with her to get it a date.

18
00:06:06.995 --> 00:06:29.475
<v Theo>Now a few shorter items from around City Hall. The council voted eight to nothing to approve three resolutions for a long-delayed hillside development on Kenilworth Road in District Four, first approved in 2006. Councilmember Ramachandran said the developer plans meetings every two weeks with neighbors about noise, debris and dust, and construction is to resume in the spring.

19
00:06:29.475 --> 00:06:57.075
<v Maya>The consent calendar passed eight to nothing, with Councilmember Houston's no on one item noted for the record. That item introduces an ordinance selling the city's six-tenths of an acre of Garfield Park to Oakland Unified for five hundred ninety-seven thousand, five hundred dollars, less closing costs. Houston argued that land is worth more than money, and proposed land swaps with the district. Final passage is set for December first.

20
00:06:57.075 --> 00:07:09.395
<v Theo>Last week we said the Rules Committee would take up the Mayor's appointment of Deidra Somerville to the Planning Commission. On Thursday it sent the appointment to the full council's December first meeting, on the consent calendar, three to nothing.

21
00:07:09.395 --> 00:07:19.635
<v Maya>And a councilmember announced a free holiday event at the Oakland stadium on December thirteenth, from eleven to four, with youth baseball training and toy and food giveaways.

22
00:07:22.191 --> 00:07:40.191
<v Maya>Before we go, here's what's ahead. Next Tuesday the council's committees hold special meetings. At nine-thirty, Finance and Management takes up a one-year extension of the city's parking operator contract, through the end of 2027, for up to about four point one million dollars.

23
00:07:40.191 --> 00:07:52.751
<v Theo>At eleven-thirty, Public Works and Transportation considers a fifteen point two million dollar construction contract for the Embarcadero West rail safety project, and a consultant for future solid waste franchising.

24
00:07:52.751 --> 00:08:10.911
<v Maya>At one-thirty, Community and Economic Development considers a fifteen-year license for the nonprofit Oakland United Club to repair and run the Oakport Field athletic complex. At four, Life Enrichment weighs adding eight hundred thousand dollars to a contract for substitute teachers.

25
00:08:10.911 --> 00:08:32.431
<v Theo>At five, Public Safety takes up the police department's ShotSpotter reports, including whether the city should keep using the gunshot detection system, plus a report on last month's 911 outage. The police towing contract we told you about last week has moved to December eighth. And on Thursday, the Rules Committee considers a mayoral appointment to the Rent Board.

26
00:08:34.966 --> 00:08:41.206
<v Maya>Hear something we got wrong? There's a link on this episode's page to tell us, and we read corrections on air.

27
00:08:41.206 --> 00:08:44.566
<v Maya>That's the news from City Hall. See you after the next meeting.
