WEBVTT

1
00:00:07.111 --> 00:00:11.231
<v Maya>This is CivicFM, with the week at San Jose City Hall.

2
00:00:12.071 --> 00:00:28.396
<v Maya>The City Council adopts a temporary moratorium on new detention facilities. The Planning Commission turns down a developer seeking permit terms that city staff said would never expire. And the city moves to bring the 2028 Olympic torch through town.

3
00:00:28.396 --> 00:00:35.231
<v Maya>This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

4
00:00:39.859 --> 00:00:55.394
<v Maya>We start with the City Council, which met Tuesday, on election day, and voted on a temporary moratorium on new detention and custodial facilities in San Jose. Speakers described the vote as extending a forty-five-day moratorium the council adopted earlier.

5
00:00:55.394 --> 00:01:21.009
<v Maya>According to the agenda, the council adopted an interim ordinance. It temporarily bars the city from accepting, processing or approving applications to open, expand or change the use of such facilities, on private and public property alike, as far as state and federal law allow. The council also accepted a staff status report on studying the facilities' impacts and writing land use rules for them. It passed unanimously.

6
00:01:21.009 --> 00:01:22.769
<v Theo>How long does this pause last?

7
00:01:22.769 --> 00:01:27.784
<v Maya>That's unclear. Neither the agenda nor anything said at the meeting gives the length of the extension.

8
00:01:27.784 --> 00:02:13.209
<v Theo>There was no staff presentation. One councilmember said the disruption from an increased ICE presence had strengthened his belief that ICE harms the community rather than protecting it. Another called the moratorium a matter of human dignity and of protecting immigrant communities. He said it's about getting the decision right, not about stopping progress. In public comment, speakers from two organizations urged the council to extend the moratorium, and one asked that it cover both private and public property. One of them said five other cities and two counties have adopted temporary moratoriums. An online commenter argued that enforcement should focus on violent offenders, and cited harm to the hospitality, construction and farming industries.

9
00:02:13.209 --> 00:02:30.499
<v Maya>Staff's work toward permanent rules continues: research, policy development, community outreach and environmental review. The next night, planning staff told the Planning Commission that citywide planning staff has been assigned to write ordinances and standards for handling future detention centers.

10
00:02:32.875 --> 00:02:58.895
<v Theo>Our next story comes from Wednesday's Planning Commission, where a developer appealed its own approval. The Planning Director had approved a seven-story, 264-unit apartment building at 741 South Winchester Boulevard. The site is a parking lot where a movie theater stood until 2014. The application came in under the state's builder's remedy law, so the city has to treat the project as consistent with its general plan and zoning.

11
00:02:58.895 --> 00:03:02.575
<v Maya>So why would a developer appeal a project that was approved?

12
00:03:02.575 --> 00:03:28.135
<v Theo>It wanted changes to the conditions setting when the permit and its state vested rights expire, and to the city's inclusionary housing and public works requirements. City staff and the city attorney's office said the wording it asked for would let the permit last indefinitely. Staff said the developer already gets two years, plus two one-year extensions, so about four years in all. Staff added that, in their experience, the city has never denied one of those extensions.

13
00:03:28.135 --> 00:03:44.355
<v Maya>The applicant's representative said the developer applied three years ago, when conditions were better, and now can't get financing. Drawings and building permits alone would take about two years, the representative said. Here's a commissioner asking the applicant's representative to name a deadline.

14
00:03:45.005 --> 00:03:49.265
<v A commissioner (from the meeting)>For today's discussion, you would prefer it stay indefinite because that's what the the talking...

15
00:03:49.825 --> 00:03:51.265
<v The applicant's representative (from the meeting)>Indefinite is not a number.

16
00:03:51.265 --> 00:03:54.055
<v A commissioner (from the meeting)>So... Well, that's what I'm saying. Can you give a number? Or...

17
00:03:54.375 --> 00:03:56.695
<v The applicant's representative (from the meeting)>I'm not I'm not in a position to say a

18
00:03:56.695 --> 00:03:57.415
<v A commissioner (from the meeting)>number like that.

19
00:03:57.900 --> 00:04:39.925
<v Theo>The chair said the city was already offering more time than state law requires. The commission denied the appeal and upheld the approval. No vote count was announced, but all eight commissioners present voted yes on the roll call. Three were absent. As staff recommended, the commission removed two conditions that asked for voluntary contributions to bike lanes and traffic signals. It also adopted findings rejecting the developer's fallback, which it asked for in its August appeal: getting those same permit terms through a concession under the state density bonus law. A letter the afternoon of the hearing pressed for it again, and staff called the request untimely.

20
00:04:39.925 --> 00:04:51.580
<v Maya>And staff said a developer that has made a good-faith effort can also get an amendment that starts the clock again. Staff said some projects have held their approvals for eight years before they were built.

21
00:04:53.785 --> 00:05:08.230
<v Maya>Our third story is the Olympic torch. On Tuesday, the council authorized the City Manager's office to negotiate and sign a torch relay agreement with L A twenty-eight, the organizing committee for the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games.

22
00:05:08.230 --> 00:05:10.310
<v Theo>Who pays for it?

23
00:05:10.310 --> 00:05:38.930
<v Maya>Councilmember Pamela Campos, of District 2, asked to discuss the item before the consent vote, with questions about cost and the risk to the general fund. Staff said the organizers had reached out to the mayor's office as they line up host cities across the country. The costs cover a torch procession, plus an optional cauldron lighting that can't happen without the procession. Staff said the biggest cost drivers are the length of the route, its destinations and security, and those will be refined in negotiations.

24
00:05:38.930 --> 00:06:02.770
<v Theo>If fundraising falls short, staff said it would first try to renegotiate the terms, and failing that, bring an alternative funding proposal to the council. The approval directs staff to do exactly that, including any budget actions. Campos said she supports the item, but urged the administration to limit the risk to the community, given the budget challenges the city projects. It passed unanimously with the rest of the consent calendar.

25
00:06:02.770 --> 00:06:08.345
<v Maya>Staff expects the torch to come through town around June or July, and plans to refine the costs before then.

26
00:06:10.551 --> 00:06:36.491
<v Theo>Now some shorter items from around City Hall. The council interviewed six applicants and filled five public seats on the boards that oversee the city's two pension systems. Three of the applicants were sitting trustees. Vice Mayor Pam Foley, drawing on her time as the council's liaison to both boards, asked each applicant what a trustee's fiduciary duty means to them. The appointments passed unanimously, and most of the terms begin December first.

27
00:06:36.491 --> 00:07:03.671
<v Maya>Earlier in the meeting, on the consent calendar, the council appointed the retiree representative to the Federated retirement board. The retiree association sent only one name, and Councilmember Bien Doan, of District 7, asked why. The clerk said the association may send up to three names but doesn't have to. Three public speakers questioned the appointment, and one asked for an election so that about four thousand retirees could choose. The appointment passed with the consent calendar.

28
00:07:03.671 --> 00:07:21.266
<v Theo>The council also accepted the annual reports on investment fees for the city's pension plans. Staff said the plans and their health care trusts paid one point three percent of their assets to outside investment managers in 2025. Staff added that incentive fees go up when the investments do well.

29
00:07:21.266 --> 00:07:40.201
<v Maya>At the Planning Commission, the consent calendar approved a permit for San Jose Water, a private company, to build a facility that treats PFAS at San Tomas Expressway and Williams Road. The project removes thirty-eight ordinance-size trees, plus one smaller tree. No one spoke on it, and commissioners didn't discuss it.

30
00:07:40.201 --> 00:07:58.816
<v Theo>The commission's November eighteenth meeting will take up proposed policy and ordinance changes that would set uniform standards for large data centers. A commissioner asked staff to include an overview of data center projects already approved or under way, and the chair asked whether available electric capacity would be part of the discussion.

31
00:07:58.816 --> 00:08:22.391
<v Maya>And on Thursday, the council held a special joint meeting with the Treatment Plant Advisory Committee at the Regional Wastewater Facility on Zanker Road, to mark the plant's seventieth anniversary. Mayor Matt Mahan said the plant serves more than one and a half million people in eight South Bay cities. Public tours today and next Saturday are already sold out, and the plant says it's launching an interactive virtual tour.

32
00:08:24.746 --> 00:09:05.746
<v Theo>Before we go, a look ahead. Next Tuesday, November tenth, the City Council is scheduled to hear the El Niño preparedness report it asked for in October, along with a proposed resolution proclaiming a local emergency ahead of the storm season. Also on the agenda: the Apple development agreement amendment on Orchard Parkway, which we told you last week the Planning Commission recommended; a forgivable loan of up to one and a half million dollars to First Community Housing, for an outside review of its finances and operations, plus one and a half million more for its affiliate's Curtner Studios building; and proposed two and a half percent merit raises for the City Manager, City Attorney, City Clerk and City Auditor.

33
00:09:08.132 --> 00:09:14.812
<v Maya>If you hear something we got wrong, there's a link on the episode's page to report it, and we read corrections on air.

34
00:09:14.812 --> 00:09:18.492
<v Maya>That's the news from City Hall. See you after the next meeting.
