WEBVTT

1
00:00:06.871 --> 00:00:11.431
<v Maya>This is CivicFM, with the week at San Francisco City Hall.

2
00:00:12.031 --> 00:00:30.431
<v Maya>Planning commissioners recommend that the Board scale back a supervisor's proposed rules for replacing demolished homes. The Mayor and Supervisor Chyanne Chen differ over the Crocker Amazon Park redesign. And the Board president proposes a thirty-dollar minimum wage at the airport.

3
00:00:30.431 --> 00:00:37.551
<v Maya>This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

4
00:00:42.145 --> 00:01:06.545
<v Maya>Our top story this week: what developers owe when they tear down homes. On Thursday, November fifth, the Planning Commission took up an ordinance from Supervisor Chyanne Chen, who represents District Eleven. It would change how many affordable units a developer has to build to replace the homes it demolishes, with stricter rules for neighborhoods the city maps as priority equity geographies.

5
00:01:06.545 --> 00:01:21.745
<v Theo>In those neighborhoods, when tenants' incomes aren't known, city staff said the share of replacement units that must be affordable would rise from about fifty-one percent to about sixty-nine. The ordinance would also add blocks south of Ocean Avenue to the area.

6
00:01:21.745 --> 00:01:51.425
<v Maya>Staff recommended a new kind of action, disapproval unless modified, with three changes: keep the current five-year look-back period, drop the special rules for those neighborhoods, and drop the map change. Staff argued that raising obligations without offsets could make fewer housing projects financially feasible. They also said that of eight demolition applications since the city's tenant protection ordinance took effect in February, none were in those neighborhoods.

7
00:01:51.425 --> 00:02:18.585
<v Theo>Public comment ran the other way. About twenty speakers all backed the ordinance. Several were low-income residents, mostly families and seniors living in Chinatown single-room-occupancy hotels, who described crowded rooms and a fear of being priced out if their buildings are rebuilt. Tenant and community groups from the Mission, SoMa, Bayview Hunters Point and Chinatown argued that citywide standards don't fit the lower incomes in those neighborhoods.

8
00:02:18.585 --> 00:02:42.145
<v Maya>Supervisor Chen told the commission she was open to dropping the map change and keeping the five-year look-back. She said she could also accept keeping rent-controlled replacement units, if the department commits to finding ways to provide units for extremely low-income households. But she would not accept dropping the deeper affordability those rules require, which she called the legislation's core intent.

9
00:02:42.145 --> 00:03:00.225
<v Theo>On the dais, Commissioner Lydia So said the ordinance would create a parallel rulebook for an area with no demolition applications this year, and that extremely low-income households are better served through the housing trust fund. Commissioner Elizabeth Macdonald countered that a citywide standard is not an equitable standard.

10
00:03:00.225 --> 00:03:23.745
<v Maya>The commission followed the staff recommendation, five to two, with Commissioners Malea Chavez and Elizabeth Macdonald voting no. The motion also encourages the Board of Supervisors to increase protections for extremely low-income tenants. The recommendation now goes to the Board, where the Land Use and Transportation Committee could take up the amendments Supervisor Chen said she would accept.

11
00:03:26.360 --> 00:03:58.920
<v Theo>Our next story is from Tuesday's Board of Supervisors meeting and the Mayor's monthly appearance. Supervisor Chyanne Chen, whose District Eleven takes in Crocker Amazon, used her question on the park's redesign by Rec and Park and the Giants Community Fund. She said many residents see it as turning natural, flexible open space into a fenced, specialized facility. She asked that one more ballfield planned as artificial turf stay natural grass, and that the city save more mature trees, cut back restrictive fencing, and upgrade the clubhouse.

12
00:03:58.920 --> 00:04:27.480
<v Maya>The Mayor said Rec and Park had listened to the community, changed the design, and put in an additional eight million dollars. By his account, the revision moves the natural grass field east toward the hillside, adds three large grassy areas, and plants enough new trees to leave the park with ninety-eight more than today. He said the new baseball fencing would stay open during park hours, and that a clubhouse renovation needs separate funding the city is looking for.

13
00:04:27.480 --> 00:04:55.080
<v Theo>Later, in public comment, about a dozen speakers opposed the current design. They objected to artificial turf, citing microplastics and heat, and to tree removal, fencing and stadium lights. Several urged the board to adopt a community alternative its backers call the People's Plan. One said Rec and Park staff had confirmed the new trees can't be planted at the ballfields, so apart from some in the parking lot, they'd go elsewhere in the park system.

14
00:04:55.080 --> 00:05:03.640
<v Maya>There was no vote. The Mayor committed to keep talking with Supervisor Chen, and said he has asked Rec and Park to stay engaged with her office.

15
00:05:06.186 --> 00:05:21.786
<v Maya>Our third story: pay at the airport. During Tuesday's introductions, Board President Rafael Mandelman introduced legislation to raise minimum pay for workers at San Francisco International Airport to thirty dollars an hour by twenty-thirty.

16
00:05:21.786 --> 00:05:31.626
<v Theo>The airport sits in San Mateo County, but the city owns and runs it, and he argued that gives the city a direct stake. Here's the board president, making his case.

17
00:05:32.276 --> 00:05:42.636
<v The chair (from the meeting)>Many of these workers are working more than one job to get by. They work double shifts and sixteen hour days. Some go from the end of a shift to their car in an airport parking lot, and that is where they sleep.

18
00:05:43.531 --> 00:06:01.451
<v Maya>He said many airport workers live in San Mateo County, where he put housing and transportation costs about twenty-four percent higher than in San Francisco. He listed eight colleagues as cosponsors. Because it was only introduced, the legislation goes to a committee before any vote.

19
00:06:04.036 --> 00:06:06.996
<v Theo>Now a few shorter items from around City Hall.

20
00:06:06.996 --> 00:06:24.036
<v Maya>The Board of Supervisors adopted a resolution declaring its intent to rename Cesar Chavez Street as Las Campesinas Street, to honor women leaders in the labor movement. The resolution, from Supervisor Jackie Fielder, passed eleven to nothing without discussion.

21
00:06:24.036 --> 00:06:51.076
<v Theo>On Thursday, the Planning Commission denied the owners of 85 Liberty Street permission to remove an unauthorized ground-floor apartment and turn it into bike storage. Staff said voter rolls show people lived there from 2012 to 2021, and that the unit could be legalized. The owners said the cost was more than they could afford. The vote was five to one, with President Amy Campbell voting no, so the owners must now legalize the unit.

22
00:06:51.076 --> 00:07:24.116
<v Maya>At the same meeting, the commission went against a staff recommendation of denial and approved a doorway joining two condos at 1170 Sacramento Street on Nob Hill, so a multigenerational family can move between them. The homeowners association had opposed cutting into a shared wall after a seismic retrofit. The vote was five to one, with Commissioner Mike Chen voting no, on condition that the two units be restored on any future sale, though staff said that condition may not be legally enforceable.

23
00:07:24.116 --> 00:07:42.796
<v Theo>On November fifth, the commission voted seven to nothing to approve an adult sex venue, a bathhouse, at 40 Twelfth Street. Staff said it would be the first authorized since the Planning Code was amended in 2022 to make the use legal. Conditions require noise control, lighting and security.

24
00:07:42.796 --> 00:07:56.996
<v Maya>The Board also closed out a hearing it had kept open since 2020 to track police reforms recommended by the U.S. Department of Justice, after continuing it twenty times. Supervisor Shamann Walton asked that it be filed.

25
00:07:56.996 --> 00:08:12.996
<v Theo>At his appearance, the Mayor pointed to a hundred-million-dollar gift to city parks from a private donor, announced the day before, with an initial thirty-nine million to speed five park projects, in SoMa, the Mission, Bayview Hunters Point, Potrero Hill and Downtown.

26
00:08:12.996 --> 00:08:26.276
<v Maya>And last week we told you the Jefferson Airplane House at 2400 Fulton Street passed its first reading as a city landmark. On Tuesday it got final passage on the consent agenda, eleven to nothing.

27
00:08:28.822 --> 00:09:05.782
<v Theo>Before we go, a look ahead to next Tuesday, November seventeenth, at the Board of Supervisors. Final votes are scheduled on the Transamerica Pyramid and the other new landmarks, the labor contract extensions, higher relocation payments after Ellis Act evictions, and permits for home kitchen food businesses. The board is set to take a first vote on letting tourist-hotel workers sue over cleaning and disease-prevention violations. And if its Land Use committee sends it over on Monday, it may take up an urgency ordinance from Supervisor Shamann Walton extending the citywide moratorium on data centers by ten months and fifteen days, which needs nine votes.

28
00:09:08.378 --> 00:09:15.098
<v Maya>If you hear something we got wrong, there's a link on the episode's page to tell us, and corrections are read on air.

29
00:09:15.098 --> 00:09:18.458
<v Maya>That's the news from City Hall. See you after the next meeting.
